Reopening of minor issue case (1920 x 640 px)

Italian citizenship: how to request a review of an application rejected because of the “minor issue”

The Supreme Court’s new approach and the review procedure

A parent’s naturalization while the child was a minor does not, in itself, break the transmission of citizenship: those rejected because of the minor issue can request a review, although approval is not automatically guaranteed

Recent developments in case law on Italian citizenship by descent have opened up new possibilities for those who previously received a rejection because of the so-called “minor issue”. Thanks to the change in interpretation, some applicants can now request a new assessment of their file through a review procedure.

This opportunity concerns, in particular, the descendants of Italian citizens whose applications were rejected because the voluntary naturalization of the Italian ancestor, which took place while the child was still a minor, had been considered to break the transmission of citizenship.

The new interpretations of the minor issue

The interpretative framework had been set by Ministry of the Interior Circular No. 43347 of 3 October 2024, issued following a ruling by the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation. Under that approach, a parent’s voluntary naturalization in a foreign country while the child was a minor could break the line of transmission of Italian citizenship, jeopardizing the descendants’ right to recognition.

The situation changed on 26 July 2026, when the Supreme Court of Cassation adopted a new interpretation, clarifying that a parent’s naturalization does not, in itself, break the transmission of citizenship to their descendants.

Subsequently, on 10 August 2026, the Ministry of the Interior published new instructions to Italian consulates and municipalities, clarifying how the new approach should be applied. Among the most significant consequences is the possibility of requesting a review of applications previously rejected on the basis of the minor issue.

It is important to stress that this possibility does not mean that all negative decisions are automatically reopened: it must be verified that the original reason for rejection actually falls within the scope of the new interpretation.

What documents are needed to request a review?

The way the request is submitted depends on the Italian consulate or administrative authority that examined the original application. Some consulates have already published specific instructions and prepared dedicated forms to start the procedure.

By way of example, the Italian Consulate General in Chicago requires the review form to be duly completed, with the signature authenticated by a notary public, together with a copy of the previous rejection notice and a copy of the applicant’s passport. If the request is submitted through an Italian legal representative, the relevant power of attorney must also be attached.

The method of submission may vary depending on whether the applicant files the request personally or uses a professional. For this reason, it is essential to consult the up-to-date instructions of the competent consulate, carefully checking the required formalities and the way the documents must be sent.

A new opportunity, but without automatic guarantees

The possibility of requesting a review is an important development for descendants of Italian citizens whose applications were rejected under the previous interpretation of the minor issue.

However, each case must be assessed individually. The new interpretation does not guarantee that the request will automatically be granted, as the competent authority will have to examine the family circumstances, the available documentation and the actual reasons for the previous rejection.

Before proceeding, it is therefore advisable to carefully analyze the original file and verify that the conditions for benefiting from the new case law are met. A properly prepared review request, supported by complete documentation and an accurate reconstruction of the family history, can provide a stronger basis for obtaining a new assessment of one’s Italian citizenship application.

Your Way to Italy: our assistance


Our team is available to provide support and assistance regarding Italian citizenship and immigration law! Contact us to schedule your first consultation! #Yourwaytoitaly

The content of this article is intended to provide general information on the topic. For doubts or specific cases, it is advisable to seek specialized legal advice tailored to your particular situation.

Article written by Alessia Ajelli, Managing Associate of LCA Studio Legale, Italian lawyer specialized on Italian immigration and citizenship law.

 

Article updated on 17/11/2026