The renewal of residence permits in Italy: new jurisprudence supporting foreign nationals

The legal framework for foreign nationals residing in Italy has undergone a significant change with a recent ordinance issued by the Consiglio di Giustizia Amministrativa per la Regione Siciliana (n. 379 of June 5, 2023). This decision sets an important precedent, establishing that the lack of submission of the income declaration (dichiarazione dei redditi) does not, in itself, constitute an obstacle to the renewal of a residence permit.

The judicial decision

The judge responsible for this ordinance emphasized that the authorities tasked with evaluating renewal applications must consider several factors beyond the applicant's past income. These factors include:

1. The foreign national’s employment potential: That is, the possibilities the applicant has to access future job opportunities.
2. Relevant circumstances of the case: These may include personal, family, or social situations that affect the applicant's ability to support themselves.
3. The applicant’s financial capability: Even in the absence of a formal income declaration, it must be assessed whether the foreign national can ensure their livelihood through other sources or future job prospects.

Implications of italian jurisprudence

This more flexible interpretation of the regulations reflects a progressive view on the renewal of residence permits. According to Italian jurisprudence, the requirement of a minimum income cannot be limited solely to a retrospective assessment based on income already earned. Instead, possible job opportunities that might arise in the near future must also be taken into account.

A change benefiting applicants

This ruling highlights the importance of adopting a comprehensive approach when evaluating the situation of foreign nationals in Italy. The measure could particularly benefit those facing temporary economic difficulties, as it recognizes that the ability to generate income is not always a static indicator. Furthermore, this decision could set a precedent for future cases, promoting fairer and more humane treatment of foreign residents in the country.

Conclusion

Ordinance n. 379 of June 5, 2023, marks a step toward a more inclusive and pragmatic interpretation of immigration laws in Italy. By assessing the employment potential and individual circumstances of applicants, it promotes the renewal of residence permits that better aligns with the realities faced by foreign nationals in the country, acknowledging their contributions and potential within Italian society. 

Your Way to Italy: our assistance

Our team is at your disposal to advise you on the renewal of residence permits in Italy Italian citizenship applications and, in general, on issues of Italian immigration law and citizenship! #YourWaytoItaly

The content of this article is intended to provide general guidance on the subject matter. It is necessary to seek specialist advice in relation to your specific situation.